Fidelity AARP 401k Warning: Seniors Could Lose 25% to 35%
POINTS
-
Early 401(k) withdrawals can mean taxes, penalties, and lost growth.
-
Fidelity and AARP caution against unnecessary early withdrawals.
-
Seniors should consider taxes, RMDs, and future income needs.
-
Consider alternatives before tapping retirement savings.
-
Avoid missed matches, high fees, and poor diversification.
-
Know the withdrawal rules before taking money out.
Fidelity and AARP have highlighted the rising use of 401(k) savings before retirement as a potential drag on long-term retirement wealth.
Fidelity reported that hardship withdrawals affected 2.5% of workers, while Vanguard reported that 6% of 401(k) participants took hardship withdrawals that year.
Money withdrawn from a retirement account also leaves less capital available for future investment growth.
Why Fidelity and AARP Warn Against Early 401(k) Withdrawals
Both Fidelity and AARP have recently issued blunt warnings that early 401(k) withdrawals can erode retirement savings much more than people realize.
Target audience:
The warnings are aimed especially at workers approaching retirement age, often 50+ who might be tempted to use their 401(k) as a backup checking account.
| # | What Fidelity & AARP Warn About | Why It Matters |
|---|---|---|
| 1 | You may pay a 10% penalty | Withdrawals before 59½ generally face an additional 10% tax unless an exception applies. |
| 2 | You may owe income taxes | Traditional 401(k) withdrawals are generally taxable income. |
| 3 | You lose potential investment growth | Money you withdraw can no longer grow and compound in your retirement account. |
| 4 | Your retirement savings shrink | Taking money out today means having less available when you retire. |
| 5 | The true cost can be much higher than the amount withdrawn | Taxes and penalties reduce what you receive, while lost growth can reduce your future wealth even further. |
| 6 | It can be especially costly when you’re nearing retirement | Someone in their 50s has less time to rebuild money that was withdrawn. |
| 7 | Financial emergencies can make withdrawal tempting | Job loss, illness or unexpected expenses can push people toward using retirement savings. AARP specifically acknowledges these situations. |
| 8 | There may be better alternatives | Fidelity encourages considering options such as emergency savings, loans or other sources of cash before withdrawing. |
| 9 | Hardship doesn’t automatically eliminate the penalty | A hardship withdrawal can still be subject to the 10% tax if no IRS exception applies. |
| 10 | Some exceptions exist | The 10% tax isn’t universal. For example, the Rule of 55 can allow qualifying withdrawals after leaving an employer at 55 or later without the 10% penalty. |
How Much Can You Lose by Taking Money Out Early?
Early withdrawals incur three main costs:
- IRS 10% penalty
- Federal and state income taxes
- Lost compound growth of the money.
| Cost | What Happens | $100,000 Example |
|---|---|---|
| 10% Early-Withdrawal Tax | Before 59½, you may owe an additional 10% tax unless an exception applies. | -$10,000 |
| Federal Income Tax | A traditional 401(k) withdrawal is generally taxable income. At a hypothetical 22% tax rate: | -$22,000 |
| State Income Tax | Your state may charge additional income tax. The amount varies by state. | Varies |
| What You Could Have Left | After a hypothetical 22% federal tax + 10% additional tax, you’d have about: | $68,000 |
| Lost Investment Growth | The $100,000 you withdrew can no longer grow inside your retirement account. | Potentially tens of thousands |
| Potential Value at 65 | At a hypothetical 6% annual return, $100,000 left invested for 10 years could grow to about: | $179,000 |
| Potential Cost of Withdrawing | In this illustration, the difference between $179,000 and the $122,000 future value of $68,000 invested at 6% is about: | $57,000 |
So, yes, an early 401(k) withdrawal can cost you money both today and in the future through taxes and possible penalties now, plus the investment growth you give up by taking the money out.
Scenario Table – Tax/Penalty Impact:
The table below shows the effect of a $100,000 withdrawal under different ages, federal and state rates.
| Age of Withdrawal |
Fed Tax |
State Tax |
Penalty (10%) |
Net Received (of $100k) |
Value @65 (6% pa) |
Lost vs. No Withdrawal (≈) |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 55 | 22% | 0% | 10% | $68,000 | ~$122,000 |
~$57,000 (≈32%) |
| 55 | 22% | 10% | 10% | $58,000 | ~$100,000 |
~$79,000 (≈44%) |
| 59½ | 22% | 0% | 0% | $78,000 | ~$139,000 |
~$40,000 (≈22%) |
| 59½ | 22% | 10% | 0% | $68,000 | ~$122,000 |
~$57,000 (≈32%) |
| 62 | 24% | 0% | 0% | $76,000 | ~$90,000 (age 65) |
~$11,000 (≈12%) |
| 65 | 24% | 0% | 0% | $76,000 | $76,000 (no growth) |
– |
Alternatives to Withdrawing 401(k)
Before tapping a 401(k), both Fidelity and AARP advise exploring other options that provide liquidity without eroding retirement savings.
| Option | How It Works | Pros | Cons |
|---|---|---|---|
| 401(k) Loan | Borrow against your 401(k) and repay with interest. | No immediate tax/penalty if repaid properly | Job change can trigger repayment; missed investment growth |
| Hardship Withdrawal | Take money out for a qualifying financial hardship. | Immediate cash; no loan payments | Taxes + possible 10% penalty; permanently reduces savings |
| Roth Conversion | Move pre-tax retirement money into a Roth IRA and pay tax now. | Future growth can be tax-free; no RMDs | Tax bill now; doesn’t provide outside cash |
| Delay Social Security | Continue working/saving and claim benefits later. | Higher monthly benefit for life | Requires delaying benefits; may require working longer |
| Home Equity | Borrow against your home’s equity or use a reverse mortgage. | Can access a large amount of cash | Interest/fees; reduces home equity |
| Personal Loan/Credit | Borrow from a bank, lender, or credit provider. | Fast access; predictable payments | Often high interest; adds debt |
| Cut Expenses/Use Savings | Reduce spending and/or use existing savings. | No interest, taxes, or penalties | May be difficult; savings may run down |
But none are free:
- Your loans accrue interest and must be repaid
- Using home equity incurs interest
- Roth conversions require taxable income.
Other 401(k) Mistakes to Avoid
Beyond early withdrawals, many workers inadvertently reduce their retirement nest egg in other ways.
- Failing to Capture Employer Match: Not contributing enough to get the full match is essentially leaving free money on the table.
- Not Increasing Savings Rate: As pay grows, contributions should too. Automatically sticking with a lower new-default rate can shrink one’s nest egg by ~$300K over a career. Always manually boost contributions to at least your previous rate.
- Leaving Old 401(k)s Behind: It’s easy to forget or ignore old plans after changing jobs. Also consider rolling them into your new employer’s plan or an IRA to simplify management.
- Ignoring Fees and Investments: Some savers never review how their 401(k) funds are allocated or how high the fees are.
- Not Understanding Vesting: Leaving a job before full vesting can forfeit some matched funds.
- Cash-Out on Job Change: Cashing out a 401(k) when leaving a job triggers the penalties. Instead, roll it over to an IRA or new 401(k).
- Over-Concentration or Market Timing: Putting too much in one stock or trying to time contributions can harm. A balanced portfolio and steady contributions usually outperform market timing.
I want you to review all of these and avoid falling into these pitfalls.
401(k) Early Withdrawal Penalty FAQ
Generally, you’ll pay a 10% additional tax on an early 401(k) withdrawal, plus ordinary income tax on the amount withdrawn.
Yes, certain withdrawals can avoid the 10% penalty, including some made after age 59½, under the Rule of 55, or because of permanent disability.
You’ll generally owe ordinary income tax on the withdrawal, plus the 10% additional tax if no exception applies.
The Rule of 55 lets you take penalty-free withdrawals from your current employer’s 401(k) if you leave that job during or after the year you turn 55, although income taxes still apply.
Generally, a 401(k) loan may be preferable to a withdrawal if your plan allows it, because a properly repaid loan generally avoids income taxes and the 10% additional tax.
If you have no other options, a hardship withdrawal may provide needed funds, but it can reduce your retirement savings and may trigger taxes and the 10% additional tax.
Yes, Roth IRA contributions can generally be withdrawn tax- and penalty-free at any time, while Roth 401(k) withdrawals are subject to different rules.
Yes, a large taxable withdrawal can increase your taxable income enough to push some of your income into a higher tax bracket.
You can make up for some lost growth by increasing future retirement contributions, capturing available employer matches, and saving and investing more over time.
References:
6 Comments