Do You Pay FICA Tax on Retirement Income? 401(k), IRA & Social Security
FICA taxes apply to wages earned from employment, while retirement income is generally governed by separate tax rules.
Different retirement income sources can receive different federal tax treatment.
| Income Type | FICA | Federal Income Tax | Federal Withholding |
|---|---|---|---|
| Wages / Salary | Yes |
Yes |
Required — W-4 |
| Pension | No |
Taxable Portion |
W-4P for periodic payments |
| 401(k) / 403(b) | No |
Taxable Portion |
10% nonperiodic; 20% eligible rollover |
| Traditional IRA | No |
Generally Taxable |
10% nonperiodic; W-4R |
| Roth IRA | No |
Qualified: Tax-Free |
Generally none if qualified |
| Social Security | No |
Up to 85% May Be Taxable |
Voluntary: 7%, 10%, 12%, 22% |
| Commercial Annuity | No |
Taxable Portion |
W-4P periodic / generally 10% nonperiodic |
| 457(b) | No* |
Taxable Portion |
20% if eligible rollover; generally 10% otherwise |
| Interest | No |
Generally Taxable |
Generally none |
| Dividends | No |
Generally Taxable |
Generally none |
| Capital Gains | No |
Yes |
Generally none |
| Rental Income | Generally |
Generally Taxable |
Generally none |
Do You Pay FICA Tax on Retirement Income?
No, you do not pay FICA tax on retirement income in the U.S.
Income Tax:
Yes, distributions from pensions and annuities are generally taxable as ordinary income to the recipient, unless a portion represents after-tax contributions or is an insurance annuity with an exclusion ratio.
However, federal income tax may still apply. If you file Form W-4P requesting no withholding, you may owe the tax when you file your return. Alternatively, you can request federal income tax withholding from your pension payments.
401(k) and 403(b) Plan Distributions
The following table shows the federal tax and withholding treatment generally applicable to 401(k) and 403(b) distributions.
| Distribution | FICA? | Income Tax? | Federal Withholding |
|---|---|---|---|
| Direct rollover to IRA/plan | No | Not currently | 0% |
| Eligible rollover distribution paid to you | No | Generally yes | 20% minimum |
| Nonperiodic distribution | No | Generally yes | 10% default; can generally elect 0–100% |
| RMD | No | Generally yes | Not subject to mandatory 20%; other withholding rules apply |
| Periodic payments | No | Generally yes | Based on Form W-4P |
401(k) and 403(b) distributions are generally not subject to FICA taxes, while taxable distributions are generally subject to federal income tax and applicable withholding rules.
If you instead receive $1,000 per month as a periodic distribution, you can generally complete Form W-4P to determine your federal income tax withholding. Depending on your election and circumstances, you may be able to request zero withholding.
Traditional IRA & Roth IRA Distributions
Like 401(k) withdrawals, traditional IRA distributions are not wages and do not incur FICA payroll taxes.
| Traditional IRA | Roth IRA | |
|---|---|---|
| FICA tax | No | No |
| Income tax | Usually yes | No, if qualified |
| Default federal withholding | 10% | Generally 0% on qualified distributions |
| Under 59½ | 10% penalty may apply | 10% penalty may apply to taxable earnings |
| RMDs | Yes, generally starting at 73 | No, for original owner |
Roth IRAs are often used to generate tax-free retirement income.
They reinforce that FICA applies only to wages: even taxable Roth earnings (if early) would not incur FICA, only income tax.
Is Social Security Income Subject to FICA?
No, Social Security retirement benefits themselves are not subject to Social Security or Medicare payroll taxes.
FICA taxes were paid during your working life on the income that earned those benefits. In retirement, your SSA benefit check does not have any FICA withholding.
If your combined income makes 50% of your $1,000 monthly SS benefit taxable, that $500 is taxed at your income rate.
If you elect 10% withholding on a $1,000 benefit, only $100 is sent to the IRS each month; otherwise, you’d owe tax at filing. No FICA tax is collected in either case.
References:
2 Comments