Can You Sue an Estate for Pain and Suffering? State Laws Compared
If someone injures you and dies before your case is resolved, you may still be able to pursue compensation.
It is also true if the person responsible for your injuries dies before you file a lawsuit.
A person’s death does not automatically erase their legal responsibility for causing harm. But it depends on state law, the type of claim, and circumstances surrounding the death.
Wrongful Death & Probate Deadlines: Comparison Tool
Survival / personal-injury, wrongful-death, and probate creditor-claim time limits for all 50 states
Northeast states shown separately
Hover or tap a state to see details
Can You Deduct Attorney Fees for Estate Planning?
Estate planning legal fees aren’t always tax-deductible. Find out which expenses may qualify, how personal legal costs are treated, and what to check before filing your taxes.
Survival Actions vs. Wrongful-Death Claims
Before deciding whether you can sue an estate for pain and suffering, you need to understand which type of claim applies to your case.
| What to compare | Survival Action | Wrongful-Death Claim |
|---|---|---|
| Whose losses? | The deceased person’s losses before death | Family members’ losses caused by the death |
| Who files? | Usually the estate’s legal representative | Eligible family members or an authorized representative |
| What can it cover? | Medical bills, lost wages, and sometimes pain and suffering before death | Lost financial support, companionship, and other legally allowed losses |
| Who receives the money? | The estate | Eligible surviving family members |
| Can both be filed? | Often, yes | Often, yes, for different losses |
1. Survival Action
A survival action technically allows a legal claim that belonged to a person to continue after their death.
For example, suppose a driver injures you in a collision and later dies from an unrelated illness. You may still be able to pursue a personal-injury claim against the driver’s estate for the harm caused by the collision.
Your claim could include
- Medical expenses
- Lost income
- Property damage
- Pain and suffering.
So, the defendant’s death does not necessarily eliminate the claim.
2. Wrongful-death Claim
But, on the other hand, a wrongful-death claim is different.
It allows eligible survivors to seek compensation for losses caused by another person’s wrongful conduct resulting in death.
Depending on state law, recoverable damages may include:
- Loss of financial support.
- Funeral and burial expenses.
- Loss of companionship or consortium.
- Loss of parental guidance or care.
- Other losses specifically recognized by the applicable statute.
These damages belong to eligible claimants or are recovered through the statutory process.
Comparison of Personal Injury, Survival, and Wrongful-Death Claims
The person entitled to bring a claim depends on its legal basis.
| Type of claim | Who brings it? | What is it for? |
|---|---|---|
| Personal injury (defendant is alive) | The injured person | Compensation for injuries and losses |
| Claim against a deceased defendant’s estate | The injured person, following legal procedures | Holds the deceased defendant’s estate responsible for the alleged injury |
| Survival action (injured person dies) | The deceased person’s personal representative or another authorized party | Continues eligible claims the injured person could have brought |
| Wrongful-death claim | An authorized representative or eligible beneficiaries | Compensation for survivors’ losses caused by the death |
A survival action seeks damages for losses suffered by the injured person before death, while a wrongful-death claim seeks damages for losses suffered by eligible survivors because of the death.
When Can You Sue an Estate for Personal Injuries?
You may be able to pursue a claim against an estate when the person responsible for your injuries dies.
1. Person Who Injured you Dies Before you File
Suppose a property owner negligently maintains a dangerous staircase, causing you to fall and suffer a serious injury. Before you file your lawsuit, the property owner dies.
In this case, his/her death does not automatically eliminate your claim. Depending on state law, you may be able to pursue the claim against the owner’s estate or the estate’s personal representative.
2. Already Filed a Lawsuit
If the defendant dies while a lawsuit is pending, the case may be able to continue against the estate’s personal representative.
The court must be notified of the death, and the appropriate representative must be substituted as a party under the applicable procedural rules.
Note:
Do not assume the case will continue automatically. Courts impose deadlines for substitution, and failure to meet them can jeopardize the lawsuit.
3. Own Injuries Eventually Cause Your Death
Your estate may be able to pursue a survival claim for damages you sustained before death.
Separately, eligible survivors may also have a wrongful-death claim for losses caused by your death.
Example:
However, some states limit the availability of a survival action when the injured person dies from the injury. Others permit both types of claims subject to restrictions on overlapping damages.
What Damages Can You Recover From an Estate?
| Type of Damages | What It Covers |
|---|---|
| Medical Expenses | Hospital bills, surgery, and other injury-related medical costs. |
| Lost Income | Lost wages or reduced ability to earn money because of the injury. |
| Property Damage | Costs to repair or replace damaged property, such as a car. |
| Pain and Suffering | Physical pain, emotional distress, and the impact of the injury on daily life. Pre-death suffering may be recoverable through a survival action. |
| Loss of Companionship | Loss of love, companionship, guidance, or support suffered by eligible family members after a death. |
| Loss of Financial Support | Income or financial support that eligible survivors would have received. |
| Punitive Damages | Additional damages that may punish particularly wrongful conduct, if state law allows them. |
Important: The damages available depend on state law and the type of claim. Not every type of damage is recoverable in every case.
How to Sue an Estate for Pain and Suffering
To sue an estate, you need to satisfy both civil litigation rules and probate requirements.
Step 1: Identify the proper defendant
Find out whether a personal representative has been appointed and obtain the correct legal name and contact information.
If no representative has been appointed, you may need to seek an appointment through the probate court.
Step 2: Determine whether probate is open
Check whether an estate proceeding exists and identify the court handling it.
If probate is already open, review the case for notices to creditors, claim instructions, filing requirements, and deadlines.
If no estate has been opened, ask a probate attorney whether opening an estate or seeking appointment of a representative is necessary to preserve and pursue your claim.
Step 3: File the claim in the correct forum
Depending on state law and the circumstances, you may need to:
- Present a formal claim in the probate case.
- File or continue a civil lawsuit against the personal representative.
- Substitute the personal representative into a lawsuit that was already pending.
- Complete additional notice or service requirements.
In some claims, it may require more than one procedural step.
Step 5: Gather evidence of liability and damages
You must also support the underlying injury claim with evidence such as:
- Medical records and bills.
- Accident or incident reports.
- Photographs and video.
- Witness statements.
- Employment records showing lost income.
- Expert opinions, where appropriate.
- Evidence documenting physical pain and its effect on daily activities.
- Insurance information and correspondence.
If the injured person has died, records created before death and testimony from people who observed the person’s condition are important.
Step 6: Negotiate or litigate the claim
The estate’s representative or insurer may investigate the claim, dispute liability, negotiate a settlement, or defend against the lawsuit.
If the claim proceeds to trial, the claimant must establish liability and damages under the applicable legal standards.
Step 7: Collect any settlement or judgment
If the claim is resolved in your favor, payment may come from applicable insurance proceeds, estate assets, or a combination of sources, depending on the circumstances.
You should be aware that a favorable judgment does not guarantee full payment if the available assets and coverage are insufficient.
Does Liability Insurance Cover a Claim Against a Deceased Person’s Estate?
Yes, liability insurance may cover a claim against a deceased person’s estate if the incident falls within the policy’s coverage.
Depending on the incident, potential coverage may include:
- Auto insurance: Covered vehicle accidents.
- Homeowners insurance: Certain covered injuries or incidents involving property.
- Umbrella insurance: Covered liability exceeding the limits of an underlying policy.
- Professional liability insurance: Claims arising from professional services.
- Commercial liability insurance: If the injury arose from a covered business activity.
But Intentional acts, excluded activities, policy conditions, and other limitations are not included.
Injury Claims Against An Estate FAQs
Yes. You may be able to sue the deceased person’s estate or file a claim against it, subject to state law and probate deadlines.
Any recovery for the deceased person’s pain and suffering generally belongs to their estate, if state law allows it. Wrongful-death damages compensate eligible survivors for their own losses.
You may recover only what is available from the estate, unless applicable insurance or another source covers the claim.
Follow your state’s procedures for filing and serving the claim on the estate’s personal representative, and meet all applicable deadlines.
The insurer must pay only if the claim is covered by the policy and the applicable conditions are met, subject to policy limits and valid defenses.
Yes. The personal representative can challenge the claim, and you may need to prove liability, causation, and damages in court.
The injured person’s estate may pursue a survival claim, while eligible survivors may bring a separate wrongful-death claim, depending on state law.
References:
5 Comments